Independent Work Presentation Feedback Form


1. Summarize the most important, novel one or two ideas in the talk.
   Be concise.  If the presenter did a good job, the listener should
   be able to summarize the key ideas in one or two sentences.  If the
   presenter did not make the critical ideas clear, make a note of
   that (and explain what was unclear if possible).










2. What one or two aspects of the presentation could most use
   improvement?  These could be technical things (eg, more/better
   evaluation/experiments needed; incorrect theoretical analysis;
   questionable software design choices; questionable research
   assumptions underlying the project, etc.).  These could also be
   presentation things (eg, eye contact, posture, vocal projection,
   nervous habits, energy level, precision, vagueness, clarity of font
   size/style, use of slide real estate, use of pictures, diagrams or
   charts, ability to engage the audience, emphasis placed on wrong
   ideas, explanations unclear).











3. What one or two aspects of the presentation were strongest?  (see
   above for suggestions)